Indigenous Peak Bodies Are FAILING First Nations in Australia, Canada & Aotearoa New Zealand

“Transparency doesn’t mean it’s an attack.” That line from a recent Facebook video stuck with me. When we treat scrutiny as sabotage, we teach our organisations to fear their own members. Accountability is not an ambush – it’s how leaders earn trust.

Across Australia, Canada and Aotearoa New Zealand, Indigenous peak bodies carry heavy expectations. They’re asked to advocate nationally while staying anchored locally and that tension is healthy if we normalise openness: who decides, who handles the money and how we fix mistakes.

The problem right now is a lack of transparency and accountability… and when members ask questions, they’re told to “keep quiet” or else.

A person with traditional facial tattoos wears a checkered shirt, looking directly at the camera in a black and white portrait. The background is neutral, emphasizing the subject.
A large wooden sculpture is displayed in front of the Federation of Sovereign Indigenous Nations (FSIN) building, with a sign indicating the FSIN organization. The site has fencing and a modern structure in the background.
Aboriginal affairs advocate Jack Wilkie-Jans poses for a photo, wearing a black shirt featuring an Indigenous flag design, with greenery in the background.

“I don’t trust the current bureaucracy which exists, for example: Native Title representative bodies or the Tribunal. Especially in light of decades of unresolved misconduct allegations.”

And the Aboriginal Land Councils too…

Our peak bodies have failed us while spending lavishly on themselves and their “Allies”.

All while pretending to be the solution(s), when they are actually the problem (middleman).

A person wearing a straw hat speaks directly to the camera, expressing thoughts on leadership and accountability among Indigenous communities. The background features a simple interior setting.

The ladder is there for anyone to climb.

Indigenous leadership is strongest when it is most accountable / transparent… so let’s stop mistaking questions for attacks and build the kind of peaks / communities our people deserve.


Discover more from I-News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Kamilaroi jounalist from Gunnedah: Recipient of Multiple National Awards. d.foley@barayamal.com

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply